Book a free initial consultation

In its judgment of March 27, 2019 (C-681/17), the ECJ ruled that consumers have the right to return a mattress ordered online to the retailer within the scope of the right of withdrawal, even if the protective film has been removed for trial lying.

Protective Film Removed for Trial Lying

A consumer, Sascha L. from Germany, ordered a mattress online. After delivery, he removed the protective film to try it out. So far, so good.

After the trial lying, Sascha L. decided to exercise his right of withdrawal. The mattress was therefore returned to the retailer, and L. expected to be reimbursed the purchase price of EUR 1,094.52.

No Return without Seal

However, the furniture retailer did not refund the purchase price.

An exception to the right of withdrawal states that there is no right of withdrawal for goods that are delivered sealed and are not suitable for return for reasons of health protection or hygiene, if their seal has been removed after delivery.

The furniture retailer took the view that mattresses fall into this category of goods.

Judgment of the ECJ

The proceedings reached the German Federal Court of Justice, which submitted the question to the ECJ for a preliminary ruling.

The ECJ ruled that mattresses may in principle be tried out and checked for their quality after purchase online. According to the ECJ, mattresses do not belong to those products that can no longer be used by third parties for hygienic or health reasons once the seal has been opened.

Firstly, the ECJ referred to the fact that mattresses in hotels are used by many people in succession. An argument that, in our view, is flawed. Hardly anyone would buy a used hotel mattress.

Secondly, the ECJ compared the testing of mattresses with the trying on of items of clothing. When trying on items of clothing, these would also come into contact with human skin. Nevertheless, there would be no practice of subjecting them to special protection requirements in order to prevent contact with human skin. In our opinion, this argument is comprehensible and also more appropriate. A short test of a new mattress without a protective film is better compared with trying on a new item of clothing than with a hotel mattress in continuous use.

In the worst case, the retailer could clean and disinfect both items of clothing and mattresses before resale. In summary, mattresses do not constitute goods that are delivered sealed and are not suitable for return for reasons of health protection or hygiene, if their seal has been removed after delivery.

Attention

Even if the consumer overstresses the goods during testing, the consumer does not lose the right of withdrawal. However, he is then liable for any loss in value of the goods that is due to handling of the goods that is not necessary to check the condition, properties and functionality of the goods.

Conclusion

With this decision, the ECJ has drawn a red line. Not every product that comes into contact with human skin during testing is automatically unusable.

A thoroughly sensible decision. After all, you don’t dispose of your living room sofa after guests have sat on it.

Free initial consultation

Book an online appointment with our lawyers in Austria in 60 seconds:

Not for: Legal aid, asylum, SIS, rent, disturbance of possession, monetary claims under €5,000 (excluding enforcement)
Last modified: 24.11.2025
Author RA Mag. Peter Harlander
Profession: Attorney, Equity-Partner
Free initial consultation: book now
Attorney Peter Harlander is a senior partner at Harlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte GmbH and co-founder of several companies in the legal tech sector. His practice focuses on commercial law, contract law, competition law, trademark law, design law, IT law, e-commerce law, and data protection law.

Our Law Firm

Attorney Peter Harlander Mag. Peter Harlander
Attorney
Equity Partner, CVO, CEO
Attorney Sebastian Riedlmair Mag. Sebastian Riedlmair
Attorney
Equity Partner, CFO, CEO
Dr. Mariella Stubhann MPM MBA Dr. Mariella Stubhann MPM MBA
Counsel
GPO, COO
Attorney Mag. Christoph Breindl Mag. Christoph Breindl
Attorney
Senior Associate Partner
Attorney Michaela Moser-Maschke Dr. Michaela Moser-Maschke, MBL
Attorney
Senior Associate Partner
Attorney Sarah Abel Mag. Sarah Abel, LL.M.
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Mag. Gabriel Prünster Mag. Gabriel Prünster
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Alexander Putzendopler Mag. Alexander Putzendopler
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Dr. Thomas Schweiger Dr. Thomas Schweiger
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Claudia Auer-Saurugg MMag Dr. Claudia Auer-Saurugg
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Hannes Mautz Mag. Hannes Mautz
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Mag. Clemens Haller Mag. Clemens Haller
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Dr. Wolfgang Wodok Dr. Wolfgang Wodok
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Benjamin Schreiber Benjamin Schreiber, MBA
Attorney
Associate Partner
Attorney Sebastian M. Ober LL.M. Sebastian M. Ober, MBA
Attorney
Associate Partner
Senior Associate Mag. Vanessa Stummer Mag. Vanessa Stummer
Senior Associate
Associate Mag. Carina Usleber Mag. Carina Usleber
Associate
Jur. Sachbearbeiterin Marlene Falle Marlene Falle
Accounting
Jur. Sachbearbeiterin Isabella Fuchs Isabella Fuchs
Accounting
Jur. Sachbearbeiter Tobias Mühlbauer Tobias Mühlbauer
Legal Assistant
Jur. Sachbearbeiterin Marlene Winkler Marlene Winkler
Legal Assistant
Jur. Sachbearbeiterin Katharina Huber Katharina Huber
Legal Assistant
Jur. Sachbearbeiterin Natasha Zlabinger Natasha Zlabinger
Legal Assistant
Jur. Sachbearbeiter Simon Prem Simon Prem
Legal Assistant
Jur. Sachbearbeiter Benjamin Hemetsberger Benjamin Hemetsberger
Legal Assistant

Privacy Policy

The data controller (Harlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte GmbH, Austria) would like to process your personal data with the following consent-required services. Technologies such as cookies, LocalStorage, etc. may be used for personalization. This is not necessary for the use of the website, but enables even closer interaction with you. If desired, you can adjust or revoke your consent at any time via our privacy policy.

Advertising

Performance measurement and personalized advertising

Google GTag

Google Ireland Limited, Ireland

Google GTag

Personal data is processed when visiting this website. Categories of data processed: data on website usage and the logging of clicks on individual elements. Purpose of processing: investigation of user behavior, analysis of the effectiveness of online marketing measures, and selection of online advertising on other platforms, which are automatically selected using real-time bidding based on user behavior. The legal basis for processing: your consent pursuant to Art. 6 (1) (a) GDPR. Data is transferred to: the independent controller Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland. The legal basis for the transfer of data to Google Ireland Limited is your consent pursuant to Art. 6 (1) (a) GDPR. This may also mean a transfer of personal data to a country outside the European Union. The transfer of data to the USA is based on Art. 45 GDPR in conjunction with the adequacy decision C(2023) 4745 of the European Commission, as the data recipient has committed to complying with the data processing principles of the Data Privacy Framework (DPF). Google Ireland Limited's privacy policy: https://safety.google.