Confiscation of Data Carriers and Data
- Prerequisites for the Seizure of Data Carriers and Data
- Judicial Authorization and Order for Seizure
- Content of the Judicial Authorization for Data Carrier Seizure
- Seizable Data Carriers and Digital Storage Locations
- Access to Data in External Storage Locations
- Securing in Case of Imminent Danger
- Immediate Access to Secure Required Data
- Original Securing and Evaluation of Digital Data
- Renewed Access to Original Securing and Working Copy
- Limits of the Seizure of Data Carriers and Data
- Rights of the Person Affected by the Seizure
- Revocation of the Seizure of Data Carriers and Data
- Access Obligations for Data Carriers and Data
- Protection of Confidentiality and Rights of Inspection
- Subsequent Judicial Review after Provisional Securing
- Practical Cases of Seizure of Digital Evidence
- Significance of Digital Evidence in Criminal Proceedings
- FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions
Pursuant to §§ 115f and 115g StPO, investigative authorities in criminal proceedings may seize digital data carriers and the information stored thereon if it is presumed that they contain evidence. This particularly affects mobile phones, computers, laptops, tablets, servers, or external storage media such as USB sticks and hard drives.
Since modern devices regularly contain extensive personal and professional data, access to such information constitutes a significant intrusion into privacy. Therefore, the Code of Criminal Procedure provides strict prerequisites and, in many cases, requires judicial authorization for the evaluation of stored data.
The provisions of §§ 115f and 115g StPO regulate the seizure of digital data carriers and data in criminal proceedings. They enable investigative authorities to secure and evaluate electronic devices and stored information as evidence, provided that the legal prerequisites are met.
Prerequisites for the Seizure of Data Carriers and Data
The seizure of data carriers and data is only permissible if it appears necessary for evidentiary purposes in criminal proceedings. Investigative authorities must therefore be able to assume that relevant information that can contribute to the clarification of a criminal offense is located on a data carrier or in digital storage. Without such a specific connection to the criminal proceedings, a seizure may not be ordered.
It is also crucial that specific facts exist that justify access to the data. Mere suspicion or a general presumption is not sufficient. Rather, it must be comprehensibly justified why evidence is to be expected precisely on the affected data carrier.
Furthermore, the principle of proportionality also plays a central role. The intrusion into privacy may not go further than is necessary to clarify the criminal offense. Digital devices often contain a large amount of personal information, which is why access to data must be justified with particular care.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „Whether a data carrier seizure is permissible always depends on concrete facts, the purpose of evidence, and the proportionality of the intervention. Therefore, in the initial consultation, it is first necessary to examine what the suspicion is actually based on. “
Judicial Authorization and Order for Seizure
The seizure of data carriers and data may generally not be ordered independently by the police. According to the Code of Criminal Procedure, the order is issued by the public prosecutor’s office, but only on the basis of prior judicial authorization. This is to ensure that the access to digital data is subject to independent legal control.
Before granting authorization, the court particularly examines whether the legal prerequisites are met and whether the measure is proportionate. Only if this examination is positive can the seizure be ordered.
The implementation of the measure is carried out by the criminal police. They are responsible for the practical securing of the data carriers and for accessing the relevant data. In doing so, the investigative authorities must strictly adhere to the requirements of the judicial authorization and may only access those data covered by the order.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „Judicial authorization does not replace a precise legal review; rather, it must clearly indicate which measure was permitted to what extent.“
Content of the Judicial Authorization for Data Carrier Seizure
The judicial authorization for the seizure of data carriers and data must contain certain legally specified details. These formal requirements are intended to ensure that the access to digital data is clearly limited and comprehensible. The court’s decision may therefore not be blanket, but must precisely describe the specific occasion and scope of the measure.
The necessary details include, first, the designation of the criminal proceedings and the name of the accused, if already known. Furthermore, the authorization must contain the offense of which the accused is suspected, as well as its legal designation. This clarifies the context in which the data carrier seizure takes place.
Another central component is the presentation of those facts from which it follows that the measure is necessary and proportionate for the clarification of the criminal offense. In addition, it must be precisely defined which data categories and data contents may be seized and for what period access to data extends. This is to prevent investigative authorities from accessing all stored data without specific limitation.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „In the case of a data carrier seizure, it is not only crucial that a court agrees, but also whether the authorization sufficiently concretely describes the content, occasion, and limits of the measure.“
Seizable Data Carriers and Digital Storage Locations
The seizure according to §§ 115f and 115g StPO can refer to a variety of digital devices and storage locations. In principle, it covers all data carriers on which electronic information is stored or can be stored, provided that this data could be relevant for the criminal proceedings.
Typical examples are mobile phones, smartphones, computers, and laptops. These devices often contain communication data, documents, photos, or other digital content that may be considered as evidence. Tablets, external hard drives, or USB sticks can also be subject to seizure if it is presumed that relevant information is stored on them.
Furthermore, the measure can also refer to digital storage locations outside the immediate device. These include, for example, data on corporate servers, network storage, or other electronic storage systems. The decisive factor is not the specific form of the data carrier, but whether information essential for clarifying the criminal act can be found there.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „Not only classic devices like mobile phones or laptops can be seized, but generally all digital storage locations if procedure-relevant data is suspected there.“
Access to Data in External Storage Locations
Digital data is often no longer exclusively located on a single device today. Much information is stored in cloud services, online accounts, or other external storage structures. The Code of Criminal Procedure takes this technical development into account and also allows access to such externally stored data.
If data is accessible via a device or connected to it, the seizure can therefore also extend to storage locations outside the physical data carrier. These include, for example, cloud storage, online email accounts, corporate servers, or other internet-based services.
In these cases too, the same legal prerequisites apply as for the seizure of a physical data carrier. Access to external data may only take place if specific facts indicate that relevant evidence is located there and if access is expressly covered by the judicial authorization.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „Access to external storage locations is not legally limitless. Even with cloud data or online accounts, it must be carefully checked whether access is actually covered by the judicial scope. “
Securing in Case of Imminent Danger
In certain situations, the Code of Criminal Procedure allows for rapid intervention by investigative authorities. If there is imminent danger, the criminal police may provisionally secure data carriers and data even without prior judicial authorization. This exception is intended to prevent evidence from being lost or altered before a formal order can be obtained.
Such securing is particularly permissible if, otherwise, a loss or alteration of the data would be feared. Typical constellations include:
- imminent deletion or alteration of digital data
- danger that a data carrier will be removed or hidden
- measures for determining the whereabouts of a fugitive accused
- securing in connection with other criminal procedural measures
In these cases, the criminal police may also provisionally access and inspect the data, insofar as this is necessary to secure the relevant information. The evaluated data must be documented so that further legal control of the measure remains possible.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „Imminent danger is not a carte blanche for every securing, but a narrowly interpreted exception that must later withstand judicial review.“
Immediate Access to Secure Required Data
Regardless of provisional securing in case of imminent danger,§ 115f para. 7 StPO also permits immediate access to data carriers and data if this is necessary to secure precisely those data covered by an existing judicial authorization. This is not about free additional evaluation, but about the technical securing of the authorized data.
This regulation is particularly important when relevant data must be secured quickly so that it is not altered, deleted, or rendered unusable. Here too, access remains limited to the authorized scope. Investigative authorities may therefore not go beyond the approved data area without further basis.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „Immediate access may only serve to secure those data already covered by an existing authorization. Anything beyond that requires its own legal basis. “
Original Securing and Evaluation of Digital Data
When seizing digital data, the technical securing of information plays a central role. The aim is to preserve the data as completely as possible while avoiding changes to the original files. Therefore, a so-called original securing is often created.
This involves a complete digital copy of the existing data. This original securing serves as an unchanged reference for further proceedings. For the actual analysis and evaluation, investigative authorities generally work with working copies to prevent changes to the original.
Typical steps in digital evidence securing are:
- Creation of an original securing of the existing data
- Preparation of working copies for analysis
- technical documentation of data securing
- subsequent evaluation of the relevant content
This procedure is intended to ensure that digital evidence remains comprehensible and verifiable in subsequent criminal proceedings.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „With digital evidence, clean technical securing is often just as important as the legal admissibility of the measure itself.“
Renewed Access to Original Securing and Working Copy
Once secured data may not be re-evaluated arbitrarily often and without a new legal basis. A new order and judicial authorization is permissible if, based on certain facts or circumstances, it is assumed that further access to the original securing or a working copy is necessary and the legal prerequisites continue to exist.
In practice, this means that a previous authorization does not automatically cover every subsequent access. If secured data is to be accessed again, this further step must be independently justified. This is to prevent once secured data from being continuously evaluated later without sufficient control.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „Subsequent further access to secured data is not automatically covered by the initial authorization but must be independently reviewed and justified.“
Limits of the Seizure of Data Carriers and Data
The seizure of digital data carriers is not an unlimited investigative instrument. In the digital realm too, the principle of proportionality applies, which demands an appropriate balance between criminal prosecution and the protection of privacy.
A seizure may therefore only go as far as is necessary to clarify the criminal offense. In many cases, it is sufficient to secure or copy certain data without permanently retaining the entire data carrier.
Furthermore, a seizure is not permissible and must in any case be revoked upon request of the affected person if the purpose of evidence can already be achieved by images, sound recordings, or copies of the data, and it is not to be assumed that the data carrier itself or the original data will be needed in original form in the main hearing. The legislator thus clarifies that the permanent removal of a data carrier may not go further than the purpose of evidence requires.
Typical limits of the measure include:
- Priority of data securing over complete device seizure
- Limitation to specific data categories or periods
- Protection of non-procedure-relevant personal data
- Revocation of the measure as soon as the purpose of evidence is achieved
If the purpose of evidence can already be fulfilled by copies or other securing measures, further seizure of the data carrier is generally no longer permissible.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „The seizure of digital data legally ends where the purpose of evidence can also be achieved by milder means.“
Rights of the Person Affected by the Seizure
The seizure of data carriers and data often deeply interferes with private and professional life. Therefore, the Code of Criminal Procedure provides several protective rights for affected persons. These rights are intended to ensure that the intervention remains legally reviewable and that affected persons are informed about the measure.
A central protective measure is the confirmation of securing. Persons whose data carriers or data have been seized or secured must be informed about it and receive a corresponding confirmation. This confirmation must generally be issued or delivered immediately or at the latest within 24 hours.
With the confirmation, the affected person must also be informed of their right to request a judicial decision on the revocation or continuation of the securing. This ensures that provisional measures do not remain solely within the purview of the investigative authorities but can be subjected to judicial review.
The most important rights of the affected person include, in particular:
- Information about the seizure or securing carried out
- Issuance of a confirmation of the measure
- Possibility to request a judicial review
- Protection against disproportionate intrusions into personal data
These rights serve to ensure the transparency of the measure and enable effective judicial control.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „Anyone affected by a data carrier seizure not only has obligations but also clear procedural rights that should be exercised early.“
Revocation of the Seizure of Data Carriers and Data
The seizure of data carriers and data may not be maintained longer than is necessary for the conduct of criminal proceedings. As soon as the legal prerequisites for the measure no longer exist, the seizure must be revoked.
Such situations can arise, for example, if it turns out that no relevant evidence is located on the data carrier or if the purpose of evidence has already been fulfilled by other measures. In this case, further seizure is no longer legally permissible.
Different authorities are responsible for deciding on the revocation:
- Public prosecutor’s office, as long as the investigation is ongoing
- Court, after charges have been filed
If an appeal against the seizure is successfully lodged, the court can also order the revocation of the measure.
This is also of particular importance if it is determined in the course of an appeal that the legally required initial suspicion was already lacking. In this case, the Code of Criminal Procedure provides for additional legal consequences. For those affected, this can be particularly relevant if the measure was not lawful from the outset.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „As soon as the legal prerequisites cease to exist or the purpose of evidence is achieved, a seizure may not be maintained merely for practical reasons.“
Access Obligations for Data Carriers and Data
If data carriers or data are to be seized, persons may be obliged to enable access to the stored information. This obligation arises from § 115g StPO and particularly concerns those persons who have control over the data carrier or the corresponding access possibilities.
The duty to cooperate can take various forms. The aim is to enable investigative authorities to access relevant data without technical obstacles preventing access.
Possible obligations include, for example:
- Granting access to data carriers or digital storage systems
- Handing over files in a commonly used file format
- Creating or tolerating data copies
- Tolerating the creation of an original securing
These duties to cooperate serve to effectively secure digital evidence without jeopardizing the integrity of the data.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „Access obligations can be far-reaching, but they do not relieve the investigative authorities of the duty to ensure that access is legally sound and proportionate.“
Protection of Confidentiality and Rights of Inspection
There are special protection mechanisms for cases where the disclosure of certain data would mean a circumvention of legal confidentiality obligations. This can be particularly important for attorney-client privilege, but also for other professionally protected areas of secrecy.
In such cases, the affected person must be requested to specifically designate those parts of the data processing results whose disclosure would be inadmissible from their perspective. For this purpose, they have a right to inspect the results of the data processing. This is intended to prevent protected areas of secrecy from being disclosed without legal review.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „Especially with sensitive data, it is crucial to distinguish precisely which information may be used and where legally protected areas of confidentiality begin.“
Subsequent Judicial Review after Provisional Securing
If a data carrier is initially only provisionally secured in case of imminent danger, it is not yet definitively decided that the seizure may be lawfully continued. The criminal police must report such securing to the public prosecutor’s office immediately, at the latest within 14 days.
The public prosecutor’s office must then either apply to the court for the seizure or, if the legal prerequisites are not met or have ceased to exist, order the revocation of the securing. If judicial authorization is not granted, the authorities must restore the lawful state and destroy the results obtained from this investigative measure. The law thus clarifies that a merely provisional securing may not remain in place permanently without judicial review.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „A provisional securing remains permissible only if it is promptly reported to the public prosecutor’s office and subsequently subjected to judicial review.“
Practical Cases of Seizure of Digital Evidence
In practice, the seizure of digital data carriers plays an increasingly important role in criminal proceedings. Many criminal offenses today leave digital traces stored on electronic devices or in online services.
The seizure of mobile phones is particularly common. Smartphones contain a variety of information, such as messages, contacts, photos, location data, or internet history. This data can be significant as evidence in criminal proceedings.
Other digital devices can also be subject to seizure. Typical examples include:
- Computers or laptops during house searches
- external data carriers such as USB sticks or hard drives
- professional devices in companies or offices
- digital communication data from email or messenger services
The increasing importance of digital communication means that data carrier seizures are now among the most common investigative measures in criminal proceedings.
Sebastian RiedlmairHarlander & Partner Attorneys „In practice, data carrier seizures today often concern mobile phones and professionally used devices, as a significant part of modern communication is reflected there.“
Significance of Digital Evidence in Criminal Proceedings
Digital data is of great importance in modern criminal proceedings. Many criminal offenses are planned or documented today via electronic communication means. Accordingly, important evidence is frequently found on digital devices or in online services.
Typical digital evidence includes, among others:
- Messenger messages and chat histories
- Emails and electronic documents
- Photos and videos
- Location and movement data
- Internet activities or usage logs
The evaluation of such data can provide crucial information about the course of events, contacts between parties involved, or the timeline of an action.
Peter HarlanderHarlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte „Digital evidence is often of central importance in criminal proceedings because it can make communication flows, documents, locations, and timelines comprehensible.“
Your Benefits with Legal Assistance
Especially with the seizure of data carriers and data, early legal support is particularly important. Digital devices regularly contain highly personal, professional, and economically sensitive information. Therefore, it must be carefully examined whether the legal prerequisites for the measure actually exist, whether the judicial authorization is sufficiently specific, and whether the concrete access to data does not exceed the permissible extent.
Legal representation makes it possible to promptly review the scope of the seizure, the legality of data evaluation, and possible violations of confidentiality protection or proportionality. It can also quickly assess whether an application for judicial review, for revocation of the measure, or for restriction of data access is advisable. This creates clarity, protects your rights in the investigative proceedings, and can be decisive in effectively warding off inadmissible intrusions into your private or professional sphere.