The contradictory examination is a special form of questioning in criminal proceedings. It is used when a subsequent re-examination is to be avoided. The central legal basis is Section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The regulation primarily pursues the objective of protecting individuals who are particularly burdened by a criminal offense from further psychological stress while nevertheless ensuring fair proceedings for all parties involved.

Particularly for victims of serious offenses, repeated questioning can be extremely stressful. Each renewed account of the events carries the risk of retriggering traumas that have already been processed or are still present.

The contradictory examination enables an examination to be conducted at an early stage and under special procedural conditions. This one-time questioning is intended to remain admissible later in the proceedings without the victim having to testify again.

Contradictory examination under Section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: procedure, rights, victim protection, and significance in criminal proceedings explained clearly.
Rechtsanwalt Peter Harlander Peter Harlander
Harlander & Partner Rechtsanwälte
„The contradictory examination under Section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is the legislator’s attempt to strike a balanced relationship between victim protection and fair criminal proceedings.“
Select your preferred appointment now:Free initial consultation

Legal Basis

Section 165 of the Code of Criminal Procedure regulates the requirements and procedure of the contradictory examination. The provision creates a legal framework that takes into account both victim protection and the rights of the defense.

The court conducts the examination upon application by the public prosecutor. Such preservation of evidence may occur as early as the investigation stage. The statutory structure ensures that the testimony is given under conditions that approximate those of a subsequent main trial as closely as possible.

Fundamentals of Contradictory Examination

A contradictory examination is used in criminal proceedings when questioning during the main trial is not possible for factual or legal reasons. It serves to secure testimony at an early stage while simultaneously avoiding stressful examination situations.

Victims whose sexual integrity may have been violated have the right to request a contradictory examination both during the investigation stage and at the main trial. For victims of sexual offenses under 14 years of age, the conduct of a contradictory examination is mandatory by law.

Spatial Separation

During the contradictory examination, the accused person and the person to be examined do not meet directly. The court organizes the examination so that no direct eye contact occurs.

This spatial separation reduces psychological pressure and prevents additional stress.

Procedure of a Contradictory Examination

Depending on the technical equipment of the court, the specific conduct of a contradictory examination may differ in detail. However, the procedure remains fundamentally the same.

The questioning itself is usually conducted by the judge in an adjacent room and transmitted live via video to the courtroom. The accused, their defense counsel, and the public prosecutor are present there. The video transmission ensures that the accused or their defense counsel can see and hear the testimony and can immediately pose questions to the person being examined.

These questions are either transmitted directly via technical connection or submitted through the judge, who relays them to the person being questioned. This preserves the right to question without direct personal confrontation.

The video transmission thus enables a legally sound balance between victim protection and defense rights. The court protects the person being examined from direct stress while simultaneously safeguarding the accused’s right to a fair trial.

Participation of Support Persons

Juveniles between 14 and 18 years of age, as well as young adults up to 21 years of age, may bring a support person to the contradictory examination if they are not represented by defense counsel. Support persons may include legal representatives, guardians, relatives, teachers, and representatives of child and youth welfare services.

Effect on Further Proceedings

After completion of the contradictory examination, the court regularly asks the examined person explicitly whether they wish to exercise their right to refrain from making any further statements in the future.

In this case, the personal and direct testimony of the witness is replaced by the presentation of the video recording of the contradictory examination at the main trial. The court plays the recording during the main trial. The examination previously conducted with the participation of all parties thus replaces renewed personal questioning.

Attorney Sebastian Riedlmair Sebastian Riedlmair
Harlander & Partner Attorneys
„A contradictory examination requires that all parties to the proceedings are given timely opportunity to exercise their right to question.“
Select your preferred appointment now:Free initial consultation

Timely Notification

For the contradictory examination to meet the requirements of fair proceedings, all parties to the proceedings must be informed in a timely manner. The court must notify the public prosecutor, the accused, and the defense counsel of the conduct of the contradictory examination, specifying the place and time.

All parties involved shall be given the opportunity to participate in the examination and exercise their right to question. Actual presence is not strictly required. What is decisive is that the parties are given the opportunity to participate.

The defense must be given sufficient time to prepare before the contradictory examination is conducted. Only when the defense has the opportunity to review the case file and prepare questions does the contradictory examination fulfill its function as fair and admissible evidence.

Your Benefits with Legal Assistance

Legal representation ensures that the statutory requirements are met and that no procedural errors occur. You will receive a clear assessment of your situation and be informed about your rights and options.

Select your preferred appointment now:Free initial consultation

FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions

Select your preferred appointment now:Free initial consultation